Once Upon a Time: Stockholm Syndrome Alert

The above video has next to nothing to do with the post. I just think its fun. So I shared.

This recap has been planned to be the final Once Upon a Time recap here at OCTV for a couple weeks now. I know I’ve been frustrated with the show for a while now and it seems most of our readers have too. If you’re one of those readers who’s joined us more recently, you should know how excited I was about this show when it first started. The entire concept thrilled me and I loved the first few episodes. I was especially impressed with all the extra symbolism and easter egg bits thrown in. Then Graham died. Now, I think there were some other issues earlier but they were more easily overlooked. While I, and most of the people I know, were upset about Graham’s death, we assumed it had a purpose. It was episode seven, after all, so now Emma or some other Storybrooke resident would start growing suspicious, right? Unfortunately everyone has thus far acted like Graham’s death by heart attack at the age of 30 (or around there) is totally normal and that the mayor, who had been threatening Graham at the time, is under no suspicion. And things have simply gone downhill since then.

That brings us to tonight’s episode, focused around Beauty & the Beast. I know I said earlier that this was going to be the last recap (and it is) but I was still hoping that something would happen to kick the story into gear. Something to give me a reason to stick around.

Sorry to disappoint ya’ll, but that ain’t happening. I’m nearly seeing red over this episode, in fact. I found the David and Mary Margaret stuff to be a silly obstacle that doesn’t make sense. It also feels like we’re now getting a very different David then we were introduced to. And since his brother died some time ago in fairytale land, I doubt they’ve somehow switched places. With his character and that of Mary Margaret, the character assassination just grows and both actors are better than their current story lines. I also don’t understand the choice to make a seemingly big reveal about Mr. Gold knowing the secret in Storybrooke. As far as I was concerned (and I think ya’ll can back me up) we’ve been aware that Gold knew what was going on for several episodes now. If felt like we were supposed to get excited and think now things are getting started but we didn’t actually get any new knowledge. It’s like your friend telling you a secret and you telling them that’s currently trending on twitter. It’s not even news at this point, it’s small talk.

Of course, my true frustration came in the Beauty and the Beast story. Granted, this story in any form is a perfect tale of Stockholm Syndrome. So Belle, who of course falls for the beast who holds her captive, is a prime example. I don’t think that’s a story that tells well (at least not on a serious level) in a forty minute episode but it was told horribly here. I’m rather baffled at the decision to use Stiltsie as the beast (yes, I knew it was coming, but still) or the decision to make her father rich. Actually I’m at a loss for most of this story. I’m truly raging at the way they have Belle hail from Avonlea. That is Anne Shirley’s stomping ground and no fairytale princess is allowed to overrun it with mother fucking ogres. In fact, the only fictional character that I would ever allow to suddenly claim a connection to Avonlea is Cordelia Chase.

I’ve tried several times now to recap the episode but each time I go off in a red-haired induced rage over the Avonlea business for several pages and lose my train of thought. Suffice to say, I didn’t like the episode. So, since this is the final recap, I thought I’d do something a little different. Instead, I’m just going to recap the original Beauty and the Beast fairytale, since I know ya’ll liked those. My version goes off the Grimm version.

We start off with a merchant man heading to the market and as all dads know, daughters expect presents after vacations. So he asks each kid what she wants and one wants a brocade dress, another a pearl necklace (which really isn’t an appropriate gift from a father but these stories tend to enjoy their incest so whatever) and then finally we have Beauty, who just wants a rose. Really bitch? A rose? That’s it. I’m not saying shoot for the moon but you could get something a little better.

Anyway, Papa Merchant is happily on his way home when there’s a miserable storm. While he hoped to reach an inn, he ended up finding a random castle in the woods. You would think he’d have noticed the castle on his way to the market but continuity has very little place in fairy tales. The merchant goes into the castle (since the door is open but um rude) and can’t find anyone there. In his defense, he keeps yelling for an owner or servant but no one shows up. However, he discovers a lovely dinner all ready to go. Now ya’ll know that eating random food is stupid. We’ve been over this with Red Riding Hood but she’s not the merchant’s daughter so he doesn’t know any better. This meal is not made of cannibalized grandmother though so we’re all good. Finally, he pulls a Goldilocks and goes to bed in a room with a roaring fire. And in the morning, there’s fresh fruit and hot coffee waiting for him. And can we just say the Beast clearly knows what’s up. I love some hot tea but you need coffee first thing in the morning.

Even more so when you’ve literally got a hair of the dog situation going on. So Papa Merchant tries to thank his host but can’t find anyone so he heads out the door. But on his way, he sees a rose bush and decides to pick a rose for Beauty. (Her sisters are so thinking, ‘we told you to ask for a pony. But noooo, someone had to be all flowers are pretty!’.) And seriously the castle stay has been pretty nice but like don’t push it by stealing. Plus the Beast is kind of hardcore about his roses. Which is obvious because he jumps out and starts yelling that he’s going to kill the man for daring to take a rose. But you should note that the Beast is wearing splendid clothes. All the fairy tale versions want you to know that he’s a monster, but a monster with taste. Papa M starts freaking out about how he only wanted to bring his daughter a rose, so the Beast tells him to bring his daughter back to him if he wants to keep his life.

Which ya know here’s my thing. Like first of all, once the merchant got home, it’s not like he couldn’t just load a fucking gun, keep it by the front door and wait to see if the beast shows up. The guy couldn’t figure out how to be a decent host like he’s really going to make the trip to kill him. But Papa M is having a breakdown until Beauty says she’ll go to the castle in his place. Then the dad’s like ‘I never doubted your love for me. Thank you for saving my life.’ And again I think really you fucking pussy?! You’re just going to give your daughter up to experience bestiality firsthand just so you can live a few more years? She’s like 16. Grow a fucking pair and let her live.

But since Beauty’s got more courage than her father, she heads to the castle but has a much more pleasant experience. Duh. Has she not seen Pretty Woman? You gotta treat your hookers right. But after a while, Beauty decides to be a psychology major’s wet dream and starts to become friends with the Beast. Until one day he proposes. Now I’m all for surprise proposals but you gotta know your audience, beast. Beauty is disgusted but she’s not a total idiot so she does this ambiguous refusal until the Beast is like ‘no worries, whatever, I was totally kidding’. (He wasn’t kidding). But life goes on until the Beast gives Beauty a magic mirror that does not house a lake shore genie because that would be fucking stupid. Beauty is able to watch her family and she spends hours doing just that. Clearly no one informed of the problem with having the Mirror of Erised’s cousin around. It makes you miserable for things you can’t have.

That’s when Beauty realize that her father is dying and asks to go home. The Beast throws a hissy fit and says no but then when he realizes that he’s not exactly getting any action by being an asshole, he agrees to let her go for a week. Such generous vacation time from this boss. Beauty takes care of her dad, who was suffering from a broken heart over Beauty’s situation. Again, INCEST. Also, this is all your fault, Papa Merchant. How about you suffer from some fucking guilt? Beauty tells him how the Beast is nice (there’s that Stockholm Syndrome we love) but she doesn’t realize that more than seven days have passed. Until one day she pulls a Bonnie Bennett and dreams that the Beast is dying and begging her to come home. Beauty whips her horse to get there fast enough, insuring that even if the Beast lives, PETA’s going to come take them both out.

Beauty finds the Beast in the garden, supposedly dead. She hugs him and begs the universe not to let him die, saying she’ll marry him. And then the Beast turns into a prince. He tells her that an evil witch made him a monster and only a maiden’s true love could transform him. And then he proposes again and she says yes. And really, this is a much better version than Disney because it doesn’t include Mary-Kate as a witch and we don’t have to deal with the dumbass that is Gaston.  The two get married and the Prince insists that only roses can grow in his garden forever more. That’s how his castle became known as the Castle of the Rose.

Wedding Soundtrack: (I assume went like this)

Kiss From a Rose, Every Rose has its Thorn, The Rose, Bed of Roses, English Rose, Desert Rose, For the Roses, Like a Rose, Rose of Sharyn, My Wild Irish Rose, Monarchy of Roses, and Yankee Rose.

Tags: ,

  • Dayna_Barter

    I’m kind of flailing around at a loss as to what to think about this series. I’ve been frustrated too with the seeming lack of movement/progress/resolution or what-have-you, but last night’s episode was the first to make me wonder if maybe what’s disappointing me is actually supposed to be the whole point.

    I totally WTF’d at casting Stiltsie in the role of The Beast. He already has enough going on, why do that? To show that even after his transformation he was capable of love? But wait: he wasn’t, not really. He chose to keep his power rather than Belle. And that whole “true love’s kiss can break any curse” thing? We already knew that wasn’t true: the Storybrook curse remains in effect, even though David and Mary Margaret have kissed. Kissing Emma? Didn’t help Graham one iota. “Ashley” and her “prince?” Nope.

    I started to hand-wave all that by saying, “But that was the Enchanted Forest,” and this is the “real world,” where fairy-tales don’t exist. The thing is? They don’t really exist in the Enchanted Forest either.

    One thing I’ve loved about the stories from the EF is that there is a darkness and a moral ambiguity to them, far from the Disneyfied versions of those tales. People have dark and twisted motivations, and no, love does NOT always conquer all, and people DON’T live happily ever after. Princes are really lowly shepherds, even genie’s wishes are a curse in disguise, and a chipped cup is just a chipped cup, nothing more.

    So if Emma fails to make headway in breaking the enchantment, if David is just a garden variety adulterer who can’t make up his mind, if Cinderella wins her prince only to spend the day STILL toiling and lonely, maybe the point is that, magic or no, fairytales do not exist. No how, nowhere. This is reality; now deal with it.

    And IF that’s the case, then this show is a lot darker and more cynical and therefore far more awesome than I’m inclined to give it credit for if it truly is just floundering around not knowing what to do with itself. I honestly don’t know anymore which way it’s going to go.

    I’m gonna stick around a little longer and find out, though.

  • onlymystory

    I’ll say two things. One, for anyone who is disappointed by the recaps ending, this is why we tell ya’ll to comment. Even just a hey, like the recap is great. And that goes for any of the recaps you read on here. The views help but if we aren’t creating a dialogue with readers, its hard to know if you’re really into the recaps. That’s not like a yelling at anyone either. Any recap on here needs the comments, even super brief ones, to tell us that you are engaged.

    Now as to continuing, I admit to being frustrated and unsure of where the show’s going. If Dayna is on the right track, and this show is about being much darker than any of us realized, yeah that is pretty fascinating to me. There are a few Buffy writers on this show and as anyone who watches Buffy knows, there is some insanely dark subtext to the show, even (if not especially) in its lighter episodes. At the moment I’m a little too frustrated with the show to continue and it feels like I’d be doing a disservice to you as readers if I just kept griping. But if there’s an interest, I’m open to taking another look a few episodes down the road and see if the show seems to understand itself more thoroughly. In which case the recaps might come back. I liked the show initially and I really hope it figures out what it wants to be because I feel like there’s a lot of potential.

  • http://twitter.com/hockeybychoice hockeybychoice

    I’ve been feeling very annoyed with this show, since pretty much Graham died, and for exactly every reason that you’ve said. What was the fucking point of making us attached to this character just to kill him and have nothing happen? UGH.

    There were things in this episode that bugged. Actually, most of the things in this episode bugged and you mostly covered them all. One other thing that had me shaking my fist at the TV was the return of “cinderella” chick with the baby. They go out for girl’s night in a bar, that’s not the cafe? And it’s full of a bunch of men that none of these women know? In this tiny town where no one can enter and no one can leave? WTF show? Ugh go away.

    I won’t be watching anymore. If Jamie Dornan somehow shows up in the Enchanted Forest world again, I’ll watch it on youtube or something. But I’m done with the rest of it.

    I understand your frustration, Melissa. You work really fucking hard on these recaps, especially with all the extra research and tidbits you give, it would be a bitch to keep doing this when you aren’t enjoying the show. Focus your talent and efforts on something you love.

  • Libraryofbird

    Damn, damn, damn. I really want this show to work. Ugh. I’m sorry to see the recaps go away I have always enjoyed them. (frownie face)

  • offcolortv

    I don’t really disagree with anything any of you said. The show definitely has issues, and I’m okay with it being off the recapping schedule. And in fact, if something doesn’t change by the end of the season, I probably won’t be back for S2, but I’ll give it at least that long.

    That said, and maybe I’m in the minority, but I liked this episode more than I’ve liked any in awhile, and I enjoyed Emilie de Ravin a lot as Belle. And I was okay with Stiltsie as the Beast … I don’t know, it didn’t even occur to me to be weirded out by it. It’s actually almost like when religious iconography comes up in Supernatural–it’s like the show uses it as a basis, but it’s always kind of a different spin on it.

    I agree that Graham being killed off with no follow up or consequences was weird and pretty bullshit, but I’m trying to move on and see where things are going now. And next week looks promising, with Katherine finding out about David and Mary Margaret. And Dayna, I LOVED your analysis of that situation.

    And you guys, who knows? If the show picks up again, maybe Melissa will want to come back, or maybe someone else will want to take it over. Nothing is set in stone around here. :)

  • http://twitter.com/EllieTheMod Eleanor Palimore

    Okay, so I’m terribly biased because I love Robert Carlyle and I think Rumplestiltskin is hilarious. But I liked the Beauty and the Beast angle. I also LOVED the Disney film, so I spent most of the ep waiting for him to gift her an entire library. When he didn’t, I was rather annoyed. x)

    However, the rose imagery was there, and I think the way they showed Belle and Stiltsie falling in love was… believable. He was decent to her, he was funny, he had a tragic past (essential true-love component), and they had a great rapport. She was sweet-natured, but spirited, and open-minded. I really did believe their love.

    I also love that they snuck in the Disney blue-and-white Belle dress. x)

    I’m wondering what exactly the show is doing, but aside from my frustration at bugger all happening, I’m still enjoying watching it. I’ve always enjoyed the OCTV recaps, as well! I’ll be said to see them go.

    I loved the Snow/James/MM/David story, but now I find that I prefer the fairytale versions to their ‘real life’ counterparts. Snow is just SO much stronger than Mary, and James seems far more decent than David! IDK what’s going on there.

    I really want to know more about Red/Ruby next. x) Also, Archie/Jiminy NEEDS to come back. I miss him.

     - Ellie.

  • http://twitter.com/onlymystory Melissa Leaman

    You know how sometimes, a show or movie pays homage to a favorite movie and it makes you love the episode? But other times, for no real explainable reason, it makes you hate it? That was just my problem with this time around. It wasn’t psychotically awful it just pissed me off like crazy.

    The Snow/James/MM/David story just infuriates me. I tried watching this last episode to see if it got better and I just felt more rage. It feels like character assassination of the worst kind.

    I didn’t mind being able to hate on the stupidity in recaps, but the only comments I was getting was from people saying they didn’t like that I wasn’t happy with the show. Honestly I’d consider going back to it but it felt like no one wanted to read a cynical recap of this show. 

  • http://twitter.com/EllieTheMod Eleanor Palimore

    I know that feeling. x) I think it was a bit… rushed? But I get that they had to tell an entire love story in one episode. I just feel like they should have put that one in the background at first – a slow burn – so they could fit more in. Like, a longer ‘falling in love’ arc for Belle and Stiltsie. A chance for him to give her a library. ;)

    I’ve kinda stopped caring as much about the whole Snow/MM/James/David story. I love Snow, and I still think MM is adorable and all, but I feel a bit odd about the direction it’s going in. But I DID love Emma and MM and their interactions, this week. Those two have some serious platonic chemistry.

    I definitely *would* read a cynical recap of the show (I read the Glee ones with… well… glee), but of course, I can’t speak for anyone but myself. I feel like the show’s gotten a bit lost, or it’s having some trouble driving forward, but I’m hoping it improves – it has great potential.

     - Ellie.

  • Finda

    Personally i’d be willing to forgive the show its flaws if they hadn’t killed Graham. 
    Ignoring the fact that he was hot, he was a really personable character. I find Emma really boring and (I know we have the complete perspective unlike her but c’mon! How many freaking clues do you need sweetheart?!) dim, Mary Margaret is dappy and annoying and the others apart from the Regina are kinda dry – and I can’t like Regina she’s the baddy of the show!I just don’t understand the motive at all. Eugh

SEO Powered by Platinum SEO from Techblissonline
Better Tag Cloud